http://arts.cornish.edu/theater/th264/tragic/index.html
Post a response to this thread!
We've seen elements of commemoration in most of the films we've watched this semester, and Bridge on the River Kwai opens with two soldiers burying their fallen comrades (complete with a cynical eulogy issued by William Holden--the same actor who played Joe Gillis in Sunset Boulevard).
I want to use River Kwai to relate these displays of commemoration to their roots in classical and early modern tragedy: How does the image of the burial rite link a World War II film like River Kwai to a play like Hamlet or Antigone? Does this common denominator suggest deeper similarities? (We can use the Möbius strip to help ourselves out here.)
Any genuine response is welcome: A good question is every bit as valuable as a connection or an observation. We're trying to figure out how River Kwai fits in with the tragic tradition (and/or how it could possibly have been made to do so). Be sure to leave your name with your post so you can be credited.
CS
Wednesday, November 4, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
In terms of commemoration in River Kwai, the most striking example is the bridge itself. Colonel Nicholson becomes so attached to building an architectural wonder that will "demonstrate the superiority of the British soldier to future generations" that he doesn't think through his plans to realize the devastating consequences of his actions. (Like Antigone who is firmly set in her decision to commemorate her brother despite the fact that it carries a huge price.)
ReplyDeleteKyle McAuley
Yeah, I like the idea of the bridge-as-monument (as a way of thinking about this film's relation to tragedy). Later in the film we'll actually see a plaque placed on the bridge (like you'd see on a statue or a tombstone). Let's use this connection to keep thinking about tragic commemoration in River Kwai. We've talked a lot this semester about things being out-of-joint with the timeframe in which they appear. Ghosts are part of this (like Hamlet's father's ghost, for instance). Well, I'll tell you right now we won't see any ghosts in this film. (I don't think that's giving away too much....) But the bridge-as-monument connection raises an interesting question: What's being commemorated here? In the symbolic/diagetic world of The Bridge on the River Kwai, what is it that's "dead"? That'd be a good question for us to hang on to.
ReplyDeleteCS
In a comparison to col. Shears and Antigone we find Shears as irreverant as Antigone is pious. One has to wonder how many graves the pair of gravediggers have dug to get to the place where its just one more body, jsut an object to be robbed and discarded. One could ask about the fate of the bridge, the ultimate goal in this film.
ReplyDeleteHolly,you make a good point: We're encountering cynicism in many of the cinematic characters we're looking at (Joe Gillis, for instance), and that's not something we see in the heroes and heroines of classical or early modern tragedy. Even with a Shakespearean character like Hamlet, we may see outrage and indignation, but we don't see the same kind of wry dismissiveness that we see in Gillis or Shear. One of the questions we'll need to explore in our last few weeks together is whether true tragedy is still fully available to us in the present age--and I think the difference you're pointing to here could make a useful point of entry into this question. (The opening scene from River Kwai allows us to use the category of mourning or commemoration to think about the shift from early modern tragedy to its late or post-modern counterpart, whatever we determine that to be.)
ReplyDeleteCS