Thursday, November 19, 2009

Take-home quiz: The tragic ideal and The River Kwai

http://arts.cornish.edu/theater/th264/tragic/index.html
As I mentioned in class, this week's quiz will actually be a short take-home assignment (like a rush topic, but linked to the quiz grades).  The readings for this past week included pages 36-37 from Zupancic's The Odd One In. (These pages are contained in the Zupancic packet I handed out in class a few weeks ago, and there's a copy of this packet on reserve at the Cornish libarary.)

If you start reading at the top of page 36 (where Zupancic says ""We have a great example of this..."), you'll see that she's comparing the way "ideals" function in comedy versus tragedy (starting with an example of the comic mode, Ernst Lubitsh's incredible film To Be or Not to Be.) 

Half way down page 37, Zupancic says that in tragedy, "the acting subject, via the various ordeals that befall her, has to let--often at the price of her own death--some universal idea, principle, or destiny shine through her."  What Zupancic means is that in tragedy, the hero never appears heroic at the time of his or her action; it's only later on that you can see how the hero's actions allowed a broader ideal of some sort  to stay intact(whether it's a civic community or a romantic couple).  This is because the ideal in question is marked by an internal contradiction (the two surfaces of the strip).  And in a sense, it's the hero's job to embody this impossible oscilation or deadlock--a gesture which causes pain for the community and/or lover (but which allows them to carry on). In short, a tragic hero never gets to take credit for their sacrifice; within it's native time continuum, at least, the heroic act can only be experienced as a disturbing transgression.

So here's the question: How does this principle of Zupancic's relate to The Bridge on the River Kwai?  (Treat this like a rush submission: You don't have to write much here, and a question is just as good as an answer.  Just show me you've thought about this a bit.) 

This quiz response is due by 11:59pm Tuesday, November 23. Send your response to csheaffer@cornish.edu



CS