Wednesday, October 14, 2009

All-star segmentation: Sabotage "knifing" scene

http://arts.cornish.edu/theater/th264/tragic/index.html

Last week we broke into crews to practice the technique of segmentation on the "knifing" scene from Hitchcock's Sabotage. There was a lot of variation among the results (not surprisingly, given the short amount of time we had to work with and the density of this material--that is, the high number of shots relative to the running time).

Each crew's segmentation contained distinct strengths and weaknesses:
  • Crew 1 managed to describe the central content of most of the shots in the sequence, and they were careful to label them all. But on the downside, they said almost nothing about the types of shots and transitions used in this scene.

  • Group 2 made an admiral effort to link this scene to one of the core tenets of tragedy. (Specifically, they noted the scene's repetition of certain close-up shots and wondered about the possibility of a connection to tragic repetition.) On the downside, though, they weren't able to cover very many of the individual shots.

  • Crew 3 covered most of the shots in the scene and provided a fair bit of information about shot selection (two-shots versus close-ups, etc.). But they didn't label anything, so it'd be hard to keep this information straight later on.

  • Crew 4 made a great attempt at balance: They covered a fair number of the shots, all of which were labelled, and they provided good notes on the content. On the downside, though, they didn't discuss much about types of shot selection (medium versus close-up, etc.).

Like I say, time was short (so compromises were inevitable). But if we take some of the best from each crew's outputs, we get something like this:

Dining room:

  1. Close-up shot of husband at table
  2. Cut to medium shot of wife.
  3. Cut to close-up shot of her cutting/serving potatoes
  4. Cut to close-up shot of him talking about his dislike of cabbage
  5. Cut to her glancing side ward
  6. Cut to shot of empty table setting (previously used by her little brother)
  7. Cut to husband; he obviously realizes his mistake in bringing up cabbage
  8. Cut to medium shot of her; pan down to her hand picking up knife
  9. Cut to her contemplative face
  10. Cut to him looking at her hand
  11. Cut to close-up of her hands from his POV
  12. Cut to medium shot of him looking at her face; tracking shot of him getting up.
  13. Track in on her face from his POV
  14. 2-shot of the couple; pan to show her grabbing the carving knife
  15. Close-up shot of couple standing face to face, groans indicating he's been stabbed.
  16. Cut to close-up shot of knife in his belly
  17. Cut to 2-shot from behind his right shoulder showing her clutching him as he begins to fall.


CS