The point of this rush is to begin exploring ideas for your crew remake project: a reworking of The Best Years of Our Lives into a tragedy.
The film contains numerous tragic elements:
- Objectification (especially the shift "from object to abject") can be seen in the morphing of the warplanes into scrap heaps, for instance, and in the function of uniforms, which is at times strangely similar to The Last Laugh and at times almost opposite (Fred comes to find his uniform repulsive, for instance).
- Commemoration shows up in the form of the aircraft "graveyard," and also in the broader question of whether anyone can or should be exalted (or commemorated) for their part in the war.
- Repetition shows up in Fred's attempt to work through his wartime trauma, and in each of the three men's attempts to repeat or resume their pre-war lives.
- Até (or something close to it) shows up in Homer's outbursts toward the children.
So what would it take to make The Best Years of Our Lives a proper tragedy? We know this will require that one or more of the principle characters end up ruined--but we have to do better than that. (If simply changed the ending so that, say, Homer suddenly grabs his rifle at his wedding and shoots himself, the result would simply be weird and unsatisfying. Tragedy means more than just an unhappy ending.)
So here's your task for this week: See if you can pick a specific scene from The Best Years of Our Lives and re-craft it in a tragic manner. You can focus on one of the four major elements if you want to--and it might help to think about the Möbious strip, as well. (What are our "two surfaces" in this film? And how might we fashion a hero like Hamlet or Joe Gillis--someone whose death or demise embodies the impossible link between the two sides or surfaces?
This is just an experiment, so give it your best shot and have fun. Give me a paragraph describing your idea, and for full credit submit your response by 11:59 pm Tuesday Oct. 3 to csheaffer@cornish.edu
CS