Friday, October 16, 2009

segmentation analysis essay: step 4

http://arts.cornish.edu/theater/th264/tragic/index.html

Step four calls for an expansion and/or extension of the passage generated in the previous step, with an eye toward your film's relation to one or more of the elements of tragedy we've focused on so far this semester (including objectification and repetition, in particular--but also the figure of the möbious strip).

I decided to begin this next step by describing the setting in which my selected scene takes place (including the function of my chosen detail within that scene).

Joe Gillis is a down and out screenwriter who shacks up with an aging and delusional movie star only to then fall in love with a young and comparatively innocent co-worker. Late in the film he realizes his love interest, Betty Schafer, deserves better. But he also realizes she won't listen to reason (simply because she loves him too). So he invites her to see his true place of residence: Norma Desmond's mansion.

The scene opens with a long tracking shot: Max, Norma's butler, walks to the front door, and he and Betty are momentarily silhouetted in the dark before the lights flip on and Joe enters the frame to grab the door for her. The camera then tracks backward to show Joe and Betty walking toward us and into the parlor. As the two discuss Joe's arrangement with Norma, the tracking shot culminates with Joe's arrival at the private movie screen adorning one of the walls in Norma's parlor.

Joe conveys his message by cataloguing the mansion's moribund contents, the list of which includes a bowling alley, a ceiling imported from Italy, and buckets of never-consumed champagne--not to mention the movie screen itself: "Did you ever see so much junk?" Joe asks, shortly before pulling a gold-braided rope to reveal the screen's surface. "And look at this--her own movie theater!"

The point of the joke, of course (if it can be called that), is that Joe himself belongs to the list: His purpose in listing the mansion's contexts is to show Betty that he has become one of Norma's objects. And here's where the screen becomes crucial: In formulating his rhetorical list, Joe never mentions himself. At a certain point, his inclusion simply becomes implicit (and horribly so for Betty, as demonstrated by the shifting of her facial expression over the course of a brief shot-reverse shot cycle).

In other words, Joe makes himself an object in Betty's world, too--a repugnant object which must be expelled as soon as possible (like a piece of excrement).










No comments:

Post a Comment