Saturday, November 7, 2009

Rush 8a: até and the River Kwai

http://arts.cornish.edu/theater/th264/tragic/index.html

Post a response to this thread!

Até is sometimes defined as "blind folly" or a "state of delusion." And in talking about tragedy, we've been using the term to refer to a condition of misguided rage (or to be more precise, a display of anger which always seems to come from another place, and which doesn't make sense in the time and space in which it becomes expressed).

Just think about Charles Kane: the more he meets his goals (establishment of a newspaper chain, construction of an opulent mansion, etc.), the more frustrated he becomes, as if the attainment of these things is always somehow out of sync with the needs that prompted the effort in the first place). Or think, in turn, about Hamlet's misguided killing of Polonious (a display of behavior completely out of sorts with it's own context).

In trying to relate tragic até to the River Kwai, let's make use of the Möbious strip: If tragedy involves an impossible passage between antithetical sides or surfaces, then how might this passage help explain até (either in The Bridge on the River Kwai or in tragedy at large)?

CS

8 comments:

  1. The British officer, Colonel Nicholson is firm on his position regarding the non-use of his officers for manual labor as he sites an article from the Geneva Convention to the Japanese commanding officer, Colonel Saito. In a controlled fit of rage, Saito slaps Nicholson with the booklet cutting his face. His anger seems to be regarding his prisoner's blatent defiance of orders but in truth Saito is extremely stressed out about finishing the bridge by the set date. He is caught in the middle between losing his honor by not accomplishing his mission and losing his respect by giving into Nicholson.
    Kyle McAuley

    ReplyDelete
  2. Yeah, I think you're right Kyle--the scene in which Saito slaps Nicholson does relate to até. Later in the film the tension gets situated more squarely among the prisoners (the British solders plus the American, Commander Shears). But at this point in the film, it's as of Saito and Nicholson embody the two "surfaces" of honor or duty (to use the figure of the Möbious strip). Their respective arguments/stances can each be seen to stem logically from the code of military honor--and yet these two stances can't co-exist in the same place. And interestingly, it's Saito (the one whose ostensibly/officially in charge) who comes closest to losing his composure right here.

    CS

    ReplyDelete
  3. To elaborate on the mobious strip, two other possible sides could be that of posessing the mentality of a prisoner and that of a solder. Saito and Nicholson are fighting for the mentality and spirit of the men. If Saito wins than he dominates the strip and the mens spirits are broken. If Nicholson wins than his men support their side of the strip and keep their morale. When the two sides of the strip meet, it has officially become a tragidy becuase the characters have lost hope.

    ReplyDelete
  4. to kind of continue off of the discussion going on here, what struck me during the viewing of Bridge over River Kwai is the way that Saito directs his anger towards Nichols and his troops. he is supressing the soldiers with fear, he is alienating the soldiers from Nichols trying to use him as a torture deviceso that he can manipulate his prisoner. Saito uses Nichols to direct his rage and frustration when his prisoners aren't producing up to his standards. When the prisoners are insanely behond schedule Saito punishes Nichols, he presents Nichols with an ultimatum of having his generals work or having all of the patients in the infirmary work on the bridge, leaving the decision on Nichols conscious and ultimately for him to feel as if any deaths that would come from this would be on Nichols' conscience

    lucienne

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with you Lucienne, but that this is going full circle. The slower the bridge is build the more the men are tortured, The More the men are tortured the slower the men work on the bridge. this is a kind of Mobius strip idea where the prisioners see themselves as soldiers, but they are already Prisoners.

    ReplyDelete
  6. There's another interesting source of tension here: When Nichols is talking to Shears after first arriving at the prison camp, he explains that his unit was ordered by their own superiors in the British government to surrender to the Japanese. This is an unusual state of affairs, and it feeds into Saito's assertion that the men stopped being soldiers before they ever even arrived at the camp. (They weren't defeated in battle, which would have been admirable in the traditional sense. Instead, their surrender was basically an administrative decision.) So in that sense, it's as if Nichols has to embrace the bridge project to try to maintain the sense of purpose that their own supervisors have taken from them. (And of course this attempt of Nichol's ends up colliding with the British army's interests in blowing up the bridge--not unlike the collision between the two dimensions of civic code in Antigone (state law and natural law).

    CS

    ReplyDelete
  7. Chuck said...

    Kelly, following up on your point a little bit: One of the wierd things about the situation of Nichol's men is that the British authorities have put them in a position where their job as soldiers is to be prisoners (in that, as I menioned above, the British government ordered Nichols' unit to surrender.) So the only thing I would add to your observation is that the conflict between the dimension of "soldier" and "prisoner" is not entirely stemming from the stand off between Saito and Nichol (though it's at work there, as well). In their capacity as soldiers, the men are ordered to make themselves prisoners (ultimately an impossible contradiction). Nichols is able to displace the effects of this intrinsic conflict for a long time (through the bridge project), but in the end he manifests this impossibility through his own death. (And his falling on the detonator is perfect--it's like Karl Verloc walking over to impale himself on his wife's carving knife at the end of Hitchcock's Sabotage.)

    CS

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'd Like to point out an example of até, by pointing out its opposite. Nicholson's keen use of wit, and his level headedness gained him control over the situation with Saito. Nicholson acts as a foil to Saito which is very effective in communicating the differences between these two commanders. Also I will point out that Saito's rage and pride were blinding, and caused him to lose proper control over his prisoners.

    ReplyDelete